Maximising Success at the Administrative Appeals Tribunal

  • Home
  • Blog
  • Maximising Success at the Administrative Appeals Tribunal


Welcome to AAT Reviews, where we delve into the intricacies of legal matters and provide valuable insights to our readers. In this article, we’ll explore the expertise and experience of Rodney Sahay, a distinguished lawyer with over three decades of legal practice, as he discusses the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) and touches on the Federal Courts.

Meet Rodney Sahay

Rodney Sahay, a partner at Stephens & Tozer for the past 24 years, brings an impressive 36 years of experience as a lawyer. Over the course of his career, he has handled diverse cases across various areas of law, including migration. Rodney specializes in Reveiws and Appeals and is renowned for his ability to tackle complex and challenging matters, achieving favourable outcomes for his clients.

The Golden Opportunity: AAT Hearings

AAT hearings present a golden opportunity for individuals seeking a review of their cases.Rodney emphasizes the significance of grasping this chance with both hands. AAT matters offer a comprehensive review of your case. It is your second chance at success.

Addressing Shortfalls and Reviewing Material

One of the key advantages of the AAT process is the ability to identify and address the shortcomings of the initial decision made by the Immigration department.Rodney highlights that in several instances, it becomes evident that pertinent factual or legal matters have been overlooked. By presenting these overlooked aspects to the AAT, you can significantly impact the outcome of your case.This is important:the AAT also allows you to provide an opportunity to clarify, expand, or submit additional evidence AND provide fresh material and submissions not previously submitted.

Power of Additional Information and Evidence

As stated above, the opportunity to provide further information and additional documents as evidence or a “new case” is critical. Rodney stresses the significance of utilizing this opportunity to secure a positive outcome.Further by presenting compelling factual and legal submissions, you can sway the decision in your favour. Rodney shares an example where a misinterpretation of Papua New Guinean adoption laws led to a successful outcome at the AAT through the proper presentation of facts and legal arguments.

AAT Success Stories

Rodney recounts some recent cases to exemplify the impact of skilful representation at the AAT. In an employment case where training issues were crucial for a subclass 482 visa, the previous migration agent had failed to properly present these matters to the department. However, by diligently compiling and presenting the necessary evidence at the AAT,Rodney achieved a successful result. It is important to acknowledge that while AAT matters can lead to success, there is always a possibility of an unfavourable outcome. However, this is where Rodney’s expertise comes into play.

Appealing to the Federal Courts

In the event that legal mistakes are made by the AAT, Sahay emphasizes that you can still appeal the decision to the Federal Courts. This represents another area of Sahay’s specialization and passion. With his extensive experience and knowledge, Sahay has successfully navigated the Federal Courts, rectifying errors made at the AAT and securing positive outcomes for his clients.

The Importance of Professional Assistance

Rodney underscores the importance of seeking professional assistance from Stephens & Tozer when lodging an AAT application. Their expertise ensures that proper factual and legal submissions are made, increasing your chances of success. The firm has a proven track record of transforming negative outcomes into success stories at both the AAT and the Federal Courts.


Rodney Sahay’s experience and expertise in handling complex legal matters, especially at the AAT and the Federal Courts, makes him a trusted authority in the field. The AAT process presents a valuable opportunity for individuals to have their cases reviewed comprehensively, address any shortfalls, and submit additional evidence. Rodney’s success stories demonstrate the importance of professional guidance and the impact it can have on the outcome of your case. If you have received a negative decision from the Immigration department or the AAT, reach out to Stephens & Tozer for expert assistance in turning the tide in your favour.

Category: All / Migration